Ireland and Elimination of Racism in
2015 a year of failed opportunities by the Irish Government to make
needed changes by Denise O’ Toole (R.O.I.A.R)
The
International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination is globally
observed annually on 21 March with many events taking place worldwide. On that
day, in 1960, police opened fire and killed 69 people at a peaceful
demonstration in Sharpeville, South Africa, against the apartheid "pass
laws". Proclaiming the Day in 1966, the United Nation's General Assembly
called on the international community to redouble its efforts to eliminate all
forms of racial discrimination. 48 years later
Ireland has certainly made a poor or some would say a downright shameful
attempt to do so.
Fast forward
to Ireland 2015 surely a country that has the means and laws to tackle racism?
You may be surprised; sadly this is not true Ireland with decades of monetary
focused governments who placed very little value on social justice has produced
shameful and minimal legislation to protect victims of racism immigration &
people trafficking. Ireland in the past
decade or so has found itself experiencing growing cultural diversity and
change but is unable to protect people from racism and hate crimes .Integration
into Irish society is made impossible by government policy such as direct
provision and a vote we had which amended our constitution in 2011 which stops
Irish born children of immigrants becoming Irish citizens.
As austerity
measures have been creating increasing poverty and social problems so the
targeting of minority groups and immigrants grows and in some cases it would be
said is used as a tactic by a failing government to take the focus from their
unpopularity and is distracting the voters attention to their selling the
countries national resources off to the highest bidders in line with their neo
liberal agenda. After a lengthy recession which saw the rise of the far
right and of fascism again in
Europe this austerity is also being used as
fuel to further fascist agendas with social media being used to spread the destructive message of far right
groups . In Ireland this year we see the launch of political party Identity Ireland; we see groups on
facebook like Irish voice. Those of us resisting this fascism will know they
have unsuccessfully tried to organise demonstrations on Dublin and Waterford.
As a founder
of a voluntary online anti racism group I seem to have embarked on an alice in
wonderland type adventure of the most surreal order by trying to understand how
racist crimes are dealt with in Ireland, nothing is what it seems and convictions
are pitifully low. Unlike our neighbours in the UK Ireland has no race relation
act .This was signed into law into the UK IN 1976. This act outlawed
discrimination on racial grounds and followed closely the C.E.R.D Conventions definition of racial discrimination.
The C.E.R.D Convention on the elimination of
all form of racial discrimination was
adopted and opened for signature by the United Nations General Assembly on 21 December 1965, and entered into force on 4 January 1969. As of April 2013, it had 87
signatories and 177 parties. The Convention covers the legislative, judicial, administrative or other
measures that need to be implemented to give effect to its provisions.
Ireland and the ICERD
Ireland signed the Convention on the Elimination of
All Forms of Racial Discrimination in 1968. Following the enactment of the
Employment Equality Act 1998 and the Equal Status Act 2000, the Convention was
ratified by Ireland in December 2000 and entered into force in Jan
2001 whereupon it became binding on Ireland in international law. At the
time of ratification of the Convention, a reservation/interpretative
declaration was entered in relation to Article 4 of the Convention.
Ireland's combined
Fifth to Seventh periodic reports to the UNCERD Committee were due to be
submitted in 2014 from the quote below from Department of Justice and
Equality’s Office for the promotion of migrant integration:
‘’Tackling racism and
promoting diversity is not just the responsibility of Government. Everybody in
Irish society, including individuals, organisations, businesses, Governmental
and non- Governmental Organisations have a responsibility to address racism and
its impact on the people who experience it.
Ireland has been
severely criticised for not ratifying the cerd of 2009 because they will not recognise
Irish travellers as an ethnic minority. Two famous cases in the U.K Mandlavs Dowelle
& O leary and others vs. Allied Domeac and others ironically have lead to
the UK recognising Irish travellers as an ethnic minority and affording them
more human rights than in Ireland
Other main
Irish legislation which directly or indirectly affects racism includes:
The Prohibition
of Incitement of hatred act 1989
The Criminal
Justice Act 1994
The refugee
act 1996
Non fatal
offences against the person act 9
Criminal
Damage act
In his report to the equality authority in September 2010 on Responding to racist incidents and racist crimes in Ireland Seamus Taylor , Lecturer in Maynooth (Applied Social studies) identifies and lays out clearly and objectively facts and changes which need to be made by the government. This is practically a blueprint on how to make real and much needed change, why has this been ignored?
Members of Irish society need to become more
aware of how little our politicians have done to help eliminate racism through
legislation over the past 48 years and that this out of date legislation will
remain ineffective and unhelpful to our society in Ireland now and in the
future. As an unfunded voluntary group we have no agenda , no criteria to
satisfy. We are a group of people who frequently use the media and recognise
the educational value that new media and social media can be used for. We are
using the internet to create awareness and inform people about racism & social
issues in Ireland.
#Directprovision
Justice Minister Francis
Fitzgerald declared that ''Ireland is taking its fair share of migrants’'. The
reality is that Ireland is opposed to taking refugees whilst our government
scapegoats them in its media using them as propaganda for our society’s
ills.... Contrary to popular myth
Ireland does not have a migrant crisis or an asylum seeker crisis. 2013 Euro
stat confirmed that Ireland ranked last out of all EU countries in granting
Refugee status to asylum seekers. But what we did do was setup and farm out
34 direct provision centres to greedy business people who have made over 17
million on profit from them. In these 34 direct provision centres asylum seekers can spend on average of 4 years
getting their paperwork processed, they are not allowed work and receive 19.10
a week with 9.60 per child a week to live on. Children make up 1/3 of Ireland
Direct provision population with some knowing no other existence. They are also
not allowed attend university whilst awaiting their status. There is no
evidence that refugees have any desire to live on social welfare. This deeply
inhumane system has seen lives destroyed and corruption continued and
celebrated as good economics by the Irish Elite.
#RefugeesWelcome
Since originally
writing this we have gone on to witness the worst refugee crisis Europe has
seen since the Second World War. Politicians and leaders through the media
& social media used this crisis to push a biased discourse and dangerous narrative. Language is
being used which uses phrases like: mass migration, terrorists and swarms
/floods of migrants. This narrative has taken hold due to the majority rightwing
ownership of the press this diverts public attention to what the real problems
are.
Even before
the EUs current struggles to formulate a more harmonised response to the crisis
record numbers of people began arriving at its sea and land borders and the
Schengen/ Dublin system was under pressure.
Xenophobic governments in Eastern Europe are now overtly rejecting
refugees, Western European states have been likewise reluctant to respond
humanely to their needs .Unfortunately Ireland is no exception in this regard. Dara
Murphy minister of State Ireland said on national radio he 'could not see
Ireland having much appetite for a quota system'.
Ireland is
suffering politically from a cognitive dissonance as on the one hand we have a pride in the Irish navy for
heroically rescuing refugees in the Mediterranean and on the other a violent
abusive rejectionist stance against people whom from in the past we have
profited and whose countries our Government and its European political and USA
corporate allies have succeeded in destroying.
This most obviously includes Britain, Germany and France but also Ireland
with its allowing the US military to use Shannon Airport. Even as this is
written the Irish Government is still
breaching its neutrality by making Shannon airport available to US military
aircraft for the purpose of transmitting arms, military personnel and military
prisoners for torture in other countries, yes other countries . Through this
action Ireland is complicit in the destabilisation and destruction of the
Middle East and the other countries the USA profits from wars with. Ireland
must immediately respond to this and the calls for #stopthewar and
#stopbombingsyria must be heard by our politicians.
We need to
make a start for humanity by actually accepting “our fair share” as opposed to
brutalising people in direct provision.
Fundamentally
neither refugees nor migrants are a threat at all. If they were allowed to work
they would contribute to our societies and to help improve them. Irish people
are in a position to understand this as through emigration we have made
positive contributions to societies we have joined. We need to make a start for
humanity by actually accepting “our fair share” as opposed to brutalising
people in direct provision.
If they were allowed to work they would
contribute to our societies and to help improve them.
As long as
fears are stoked up about migrant / refugees establishment politicians right
across Europe can blame them on our own problems. Refugees did not cause the
homeless crisis, this was caused by lack of social housing, high rents and bank
repossessions caused by ''our own''. Refugees could easily be drawn into being part
of our solutions.
It does not
have to be one or the other homeless people or refugees. We have more in common
with them than the bankers, the corrupt government and rich elite1 % who are being let off the hook .Ireland is the 16th richest country in the world
with the wealthiest people enjoying a massive €35 billion increase in their
fortunes.
All we want
for Christmas is a government who will in 2016 end direct provision, for traveller
ethnicity to be recognised and our outdated legislation to be reformed.
The general
election in early 2016 will be our version of a Christmas list to our government
.Let them know that we demand change and will not accept a bag of ashes.
www.ihrec.ie
http://www.ihrec.ie/publications/list/responding-to-racist-incidents-and-racist-crimes-i/
Seamus Taylor
http://www.ohchr.org
CERD convention